Empowering your employees to give feedback

It might sound scary but one of the best things you can do as a business is to open up the lines of transparency and feedback and have your employees (anonymously) provide feedback on their direct managers.


I recall doing this back in my days at Seek and I can tell you it was a bit daunting at first and the team I was in were all a little to shy to get the ball rolling, but some of us older crew (who had been there for a few years at this point) weren't so shy haha.  The feedback that followed wasn't just constructive, it was really refreshing as there were challenges that I didn't even realise some of the new team members were having that I could help them with, not just our manager.


The process was pretty manual back then, we as a team sat around and wrote up our feedback on butchers paper and had to all agree as a group what we were saying.  It made some topics more challenging to agree on but we got there in the end.  Our manager then came in and we shared as a group the feedback we had.  It wasn't a bashing session by any means, it was very constructive and all coming from a place that meant he understood better what we required as a team to continue to excel.


To his credit he welcomed it all, there were some surprises and some things he thought he was doing quite well on, but we just expected a bit more.  It was very interesting to see that his expectations and ours were not always aligned. 


So why should you implement 360 Feedback?  Here are some of the key benefits:


  1. Empowerment: Encouraging employees to provide feedback on their managers empowers them to voice their opinions and concerns. This fosters a sense of ownership and engagement in the organisation's culture and decision-making processes.
  2. Improvement of Managerial Skills: Constructive feedback from employees can help managers identify areas for improvement in their leadership style, communication, decision-making, and interpersonal skills. This feedback loop enables managers to adapt and grow, ultimately enhancing their effectiveness in leading teams.
  3. Enhanced Trust and Communication: Soliciting feedback from employees demonstrates a commitment to open communication and trust within the organisation. When employees feel heard and valued, it strengthens their relationship with their manager and fosters a more positive work environment.
  4. Alignment with Employee Expectations: Managers may not always be aware of how their actions and decisions impact their team members. Feedback from employees provides valuable insights into employee expectations, concerns, and preferences, helping managers align their leadership approach with the needs of their team.
  5. Identification of Blind Spots: Managers, like everyone else, have blind spots—areas of weakness or behaviours they may not be aware of. Feedback from employees can shed light on these blind spots, enabling managers to address them and become more self-aware.
  6. Employee Development: Giving feedback on managerial performance encourages employees to reflect on their own experiences and articulate their observations. This reflection can contribute to their own professional development by sharpening their observational and communication skills.
  7. Culture of Continuous Improvement: When feedback is actively sought and acted upon, it creates a culture of continuous improvement within the organisation. Both managers and employees become more accustomed to giving and receiving feedback, which can lead to higher performance and innovation.
  8. Retention and Engagement: Employees who feel their voices are heard and their feedback is valued are more likely to feel engaged and committed to their work and the organisation. This can positively impact employee retention rates and reduce turnover.


Overall, encouraging employees to give feedback on their managers fosters a culture of openness, transparency, and continuous learning within the organisation, which can lead to improved performance, morale, and employee satisfaction.  So why wouldn't you do it?


A key part of our Performance product is 360 feedback as well as colleague to colleague feedback.  Two key approaches to helping you improve performance for your business.  To find out more book a demo with us here.

By Justin Hillier February 25, 2025
The Power of Employee Engagement in Increasing Your Recruitment Agency’s Value
How Recruitment Agencies Can Boost Their Valuation Before Selling
By Justin Hillier February 25, 2025
How Recruitment Agencies Can Boost Their Valuation Before Selling
Recruitment Agencies Should Be “A Part” of Their Clients Business
By Justin Hillier February 16, 2025
Why Recruitment Agencies Should Be “A Part” of Their Clients Business, not just a partner
By Justin Hillier February 13, 2025
Recruiter Insider vs NPS: Why Recruiter Insider is the Superior Choice for Recruitment Feedback
AI Driven feedback for candidates post interview
By Justin Hillier January 30, 2025
Key Benefits of Automating and Structuring Post-Interview Feedback Post-interview feedback is the biggest bottleneck in the hiring process, frustrating hiring managers, consultants, and candidates alike. Chasing feedback wastes time, the responses are often vague, and valuable insights are more often than not, lost. A streamlined, structured approach eliminates these issues, delivering significant benefits across the board: Here at Recruiter Insider we have released a feature that solves all of these problems and delivers feedback faster to the consultant and candidate whilst making the process easier for hiring managers. How it works Hiring Managers receive an email from Recruiter Insider Record a voice note on 5 specific questions Confirm the AI powered transcription Choose if you would like to progress the candidate to the next stage Submit - That's it! For Hiring Managers ✅ Removes the pressure of a sales-driven call – No more feeling caught off guard by a consultant’s call at an inconvenient time. ✅ Saves time – Instead of a drawn-out 5-10 minute call, feedback can be provided in approx. two minutes . ✅ Provides flexibility – Feedback can be given at a time that suits them, rather than waiting for a consultant’s call. ✅ Improves employer branding – A faster, smoother process makes the company look professional, improving its reputation in the market. ✅ Speeds up hiring – Faster feedback means decisions are made quicker, ensuring the best candidates aren’t lost to competitors. For Recruitment Consultants ✅ Eliminates constant chasing – No more wasting time trying to get a hiring manager on the phone for a rushed response. ✅ Enables deeper conversations – When consultants do speak to hiring managers, they can focus on valuable insights , not just asking for feedback. ✅ Creates structured feedback data – Feedback is stored and tracked over time, no longer lost in the consultant’s memory . ✅ Improves efficiency – Saves time by automating a process that traditionally requires multiple follow-ups. ✅ Builds hiring intelligence – Over time, structured data allows for better interview preparation resources aligned to hiring managers, job titles, and employers. ✅ Enhances screening processes – Aggregated feedback can be used to pre-screen candidates more effectively based on what hiring managers consistently look for. ✅ Integrates directly into your ATS – Feedback is automatically recorded and stored against candidates for future reference. For Candidates ✅ Receives feedback faster – The biggest frustration for candidates is waiting in limbo; this approach eliminates unnecessary delays. ✅ Gains better insights – Instead of just a "no," candidates get clearer, more structured feedback to help them improve. ✅ Improves the overall candidate experience – Faster, transparent feedback strengthens the relationship between candidates, employers, and consultants. The Bigger Picture By simplifying the process, we achieve: 🚀 A faster hiring process – Even a 10% reduction in time-to-hire would have a massive impact. 📊 Actionable hiring data – Structured feedback enables long-term hiring trend analysis. 🎯 More trust and stronger relationships – When candidates and clients feel heard, trust in the process grows. 💡 A better recruitment experience for all – A win for hiring managers, consultants, and candidates alike. Real-World Proof One hiring manager recently completed feedback in 1 minute 15 seconds , allowing the process to move forward faster than a consultant could have by calling them. Reach out to us here for a demo.
Role of Recruiters in Ensuring a Positive Onboarding Experience
By Aisling Corbett September 11, 2024
The Role of Recruiters in Ensuring a Positive Onboarding Experience
Extracting Value from Feedback Data: A Guide for Recruitment Agency Owners
By Justin Hillier August 29, 2024
Extracting Value from Feedback Data: A Guide for Recruitment Agency Owners
By Justin Hillier August 2, 2024
Why you need Case Studies on your website
Why Recruitment Agencies Invest in a Feedback System
By Aisling Corbett July 26, 2024
Why Recruitment Agencies Invest in a Feedback System
By Aisling Corbett April 25, 2024
The Importance of Candidate Aftercare
More Posts
Share by: